Guard against temptation: intrapersonal team reasoning and the role of intentions in exercising willpower

Gold, Natalie ORCID: 0000-0003-0706-1618 (2022) Guard against temptation: intrapersonal team reasoning and the role of intentions in exercising willpower. Noûs, 56 (3). 554 - 569. ISSN 0029-4624

Text (nous.12369) - Published Version Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial. Download (169kB)

• Author
• Scopus publication

Abstract

Sometimes we make a decision about an action we will undertake later and form an intention, but our judgment of what it is best to do undergoes a temporary shift when the time for action comes round. What makes it rational not to give in to temptation? Many contemporary solutions privilege diachronic rationality; in some “rational non-reconsideration” (RNR) accounts once the agent forms an intention, it is rational not to reconsider. This leads to other puzzles: how can someone be motivated to follow a plan that is contrary to their current judgment? How can it be rational to form a plan to resist if we can predict that our judgment will shift? I show how these puzzles can be solved in a framework where there are multiple units of agency, distinguishing between the judgments of the timeslice and those of the person over time, and allowing that the timeslice can “self identify”, taking the person over time as the relevant unit of agency and doing intrapersonal team reasoning (with a different causal role for intentions than RNR accounts). On my account, resisting temptation is compatible with synchronic rationality, so synchronic and diachronic rationality are aligned. However, either resisting or succumbing to temptation can be instrumentally rational, depending on the unit of agency that is identified with. In order to show why we ought to resist temptation, we need to draw on a non-instrumental rationale. I sketch possible routes for doing this.

Item Type:	Article
Official URL:	https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/journal/14680068
Additional Information:	© 2021 The Author
Divisions:	CPNSS
Subjects:	B Philosophy. Psychology. Religion > B Philosophy (General) H Social Sciences > HM Sociology B Philosophy. Psychology. Religion > BF Psychology
Date Deposited:	29 Mar 2021 11:18
Last Modified:	09 Nov 2024 03:12
URI:	http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/109792

Actions (login required)

View Item