Bovens, Luc and Rabinowicz, Wlodek (2004) Voting procedures for complex collective decisions: an epistemic perspective. Ratio Juris, 17 (2). pp. 241-258. ISSN 0952-1917
This is the latest version of this item.
In addressing a complex issue that is decomposable into several sub-questions, a committee can use different voting procedures: Either it can let the committee members vote on each sub-question and then use the outcomes as premises for its conclusion on the main issue (premise based-procedure, pbp), or it can let the members directly vote on the conclusion (conclusion-based procedure, cbp). The procedures can lead to different results, but which of them is a better truth-tracker? On the basis of Condorcet's jury theorem, we show that the pbp is clearly superior if the objective is to reach truth for the right (= correct) reasons. However, if the goal instead is to reach truth for whatever reasons, right or wrong, there will be cases in which using the cbp turns out to be more reliable, even though, for the most part, the pbp will retain its superiority. In that connection, we also consider the truth-tracking potential of a “sophisticated” variant of the pbp, which is sensitive to the size of the majorities supporting each of the premises.
|Additional Information:||© 2004 John Wiley & Sons Ltd|
|Library of Congress subject classification:||B Philosophy. Psychology. Religion > B Philosophy (General)
B Philosophy. Psychology. Religion > BC Logic
|Sets:||Departments > Government
Departments > Philosophy, Logic and Scientific Method
|Date Deposited:||21 Nov 2013 10:57|
Available Versions of this Item
Democracy and argument: tracking truth in complex social decisions. (deposited 25 Sep 2008 12:58)
Complex collective decisions: an epistemic perspective. (deposited 20 Nov 2013 16:50)
- Voting procedures for complex collective decisions: an epistemic perspective. (deposited 21 Nov 2013 10:57) [Currently Displayed]
- Complex collective decisions: an epistemic perspective. (deposited 20 Nov 2013 16:50)
Actions (login required)
|Record administration - authorised staff only|