Morally permissible risk imposition and liability to defensive harm

Burri, Susanne (2020) Morally permissible risk imposition and liability to defensive harm. Law and Philosophy, 39 (4). pp. 381-408. ISSN 0167-5249

Text (Burri_morally-permissible-risk-imposition--published) - Published Version Available under License Creative Commons Attribution. Download (316kB)

• Author

Abstract

This paper examines whether an agent becomes liable to defensive harm by engaging in a morally permissible but foreseeably risk-imposing activity that subsequently threatens objectively unjustified harm. It first clarifies the notion of a foreseeably risk-imposing activity by proposing that an activity should count as foreseeably risk-imposing if an agent may morally permissibly perform it only if she abides by certain duties of care. Those who argue that engaging in such an activity can render an agent liable to defensive harm ground this liability in the luck egalitarian thought that we may justly hold individuals responsible for the consequences of their voluntary choices. Against this, I argue that a luck egalitarian commitment to holding people responsible cannot, by itself, ground liability to defensive harm. It can help ground such liability only against the backdrop of a distributively just society, and only if further considerations speak morally in favour of attaching certain well-defined costs to individuals’ risk-imposing choices. I conclude by suggesting that if an account of liability applies robustly across distributively just and unjust contexts alike, then what grounds an agent’s liability is plausibly not her responsibility for threatening objectively unjustified harm, but her culpability for doing so.

Item Type:	Article
Official URL:	https://link.springer.com/journal/10982
Additional Information:	© 2020 The Author
Divisions:	Philosophy, Logic and Scientific Method
Subjects:	B Philosophy. Psychology. Religion > BC Logic K Law > KD England and Wales
Date Deposited:	23 May 2019 15:57
Last Modified:	22 Nov 2024 08:03
URI:	http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/100876

Actions (login required)

View Item